Circles P and Q have radii 1 and 4, respectively, and are externally tangent at point A. Point B is on P and point C is on Q so that line BC is a common external tangent of the two circles. A line ℓ through A intersects P again at D and intersects Q again at E. Points B and C lie on the same side of ℓ, and the areas of △DBA and △ACE are equal. This common area is nm, where m and n are relatively prime positive integers. Find m+n.
Hint
[ABC]=21absinC is your friend for a quick solve. If you know about homotheties, go ahead, but you'll still need to do quite a bit of computation. If you're completely lost and you have a lot of time left in your mocking of this AIME, go ahead and use analytic geometry.
解析
Solution 1 (guys trig is fast)
Let M be the intersection of BC and the common internal tangent of P and Q. We claim that M is the circumcenter of right △ABC. Indeed, we have AM=BM and BM=CM by equal tangents to circles, and since BM=CM,M is the midpoint of BC, implying that ∠BAC=90. Now draw PA,PB,PM, where P is the center of circle P. Quadrilateral PAMB is cyclic, and by Pythagorean Theorem PM=5, so by Ptolemy on PAMB we have
AB5=2⋅1+2⋅1=4⟺AB=545.
Do the same thing on cyclic quadrilateral QAMC (where Q is the center of circle Q and get AC=585.
Let ∠A=∠DAB. By Law of Sines, BD=2RsinA=2sinA. Note that ∠D=∠ABC from inscribed angles, so
[ABD]=21BD⋅AB⋅sin∠B=21⋅545⋅2sinAsin(180−∠A−∠D)=545⋅sinA⋅sin(∠A+∠D)=545⋅sinA⋅(sinAcosD+cosAsinD)=545⋅sinA⋅(sinAcos∠ABC+cosAsin∠ABC)=545⋅sinA⋅(55sinA+525cosA)=54⋅sinA(sinA+2cosA)
after angle addition identity.
Similarly, ∠EAC=90−∠A, and by Law of Sines CE=8sin∠EAC=8cosA. Note that ∠E=∠ACB from inscribed angles, so
[ACE]=21AC⋅CEsin∠C=21⋅585⋅8cosAsin[180−(90−∠A)−∠E]=5325⋅cosAsin[(90−∠A)+∠ACB]=5325⋅cosA(525cosA+55sinA)=532⋅cosA(sinA+2cosA)
after angle addition identity. Setting the two areas equal, we get
tanA=cosAsinA=8⟺sinA=658,cosA=651
after Pythagorean Identity. Now plug back in and the common area is 6564⟺129.
Solution 2
Call O1 and O2 the centers of circles P and Q, respectively, and extend CB and O2O1 to meet at point N. Call K and L the feet of the altitudes from B to O1N and C to O2N, respectively. Using the fact that △O1BN∼△O2CN and setting NO1=k, we have that kk+5=14⟹k=35. We can do some more length chasing using triangles similar to O1BN to get that AK=AL=1524, BK=1512, and CL=1548. Now, consider the circles P and Q on the coordinate plane, where A is the origin. If the line ℓ through A intersects P at D and Q at E then 4⋅DA=AE. To verify this, notice that △AO1D∼△EO2A from the fact that both triangles are isosceles with ∠O1AD≅∠O2AE, which are corresponding angles. Since O2A=4⋅O1A, we can conclude that 4⋅DA=AE.
Hence, we need to find the slope m of line ℓ such that the perpendicular distance n from B to AD is four times the perpendicular distance p from C to AE. This will mean that the product of the bases and heights of triangles ACE and DBA will be equal, which in turn means that their areas will be equal. Let the line ℓ have the equation y=−mx⟹mx+y=0, and let m be a positive real number so that the negative slope of ℓ is preserved. Setting A=(0,0), the coordinates of B are (xB,yB)=(15−24,15−12), and the coordinates of C are (xC,yC)=(1524,15−48). Using the point-to-line distance formula and the condition n=4p, we have
m2+1∣mxB+1(yB)+0∣=m2+14∣mxC+1(yC)+0∣⟹∣mxB+yB∣=4∣mxC+yC∣⟹15−24m+15−12=41524m+15−48.
If m>2, then clearly B and C would not lie on the same side of ℓ. Thus since m>0, we must switch the signs of all terms in this equation when we get rid of the absolute value signs. We then have
156m+153=1548−1524m⟹2m=3⟹m=23.
Thus, the equation of ℓ is y=−23x.
Then we can find the coordinates of D by finding the point (x,y) other than A=(0,0) where the circle P intersects ℓ. P can be represented with the equation (x+1)2+y2=1, and substituting y=−23x into this equation yields x=0,−138 as solutions. Discarding x=0, the y-coordinate of D is −23⋅−138=1312. The distance from D to A is then 134. The perpendicular distance from B to AD or the height of △DBA is 232+1∣23⋅15−24+15−12+0∣=2131548=51332. Finally, the common area is 21(51332⋅134)=6564, and m+n=64+65=129.
Solution 3
By homothety, we deduce that AE=4AD. (The proof can also be executed by similar triangles formed from dropping perpendiculars from the centers of P and Q to l.) Therefore, our equality of area condition, or the equality of base times height condition, reduces to the fact that the distance from B to l is four times that from C to l. Let the distance from C be x and the distance from B be 4x.
Let P and Q be the centers of their respective circles. Then dropping a perpendicular from P to Q creates a 3−4−5 right triangle, from which BC=4 and, if α=∠AQC, that cosα=53. Then ∠BPA=180∘−α, and the Law of Cosines on triangles APB and AQC gives AB=54 and AC=58.
Now, using the Pythagorean Theorem to express the length of the projection of BC onto line l gives
516−16x2+564−x2=16−9x2.
Squaring and simplifying gives
(51−x2)(564−x2)=x2,
and squaring and solving gives x=5138.
By the Law of Sines on triangle ABD, we have
sinABD=2.
But we know sinA=AB4x, and so a small computation gives BD=6516. The Pythagorean Theorem now gives
AD=BD2−(4x)2+AB2−(4x)2=134,
and so the common area is 21⋅134⋅51332=6564. The answer is 129.
Alternate Path to x
Call the intersection of lines l and BCE.You can use similar triangles to find that the distance from B to E is four times the distance from C to E. Then draw a perpendicular from A to BC and call the point F. AF=58 and FE=FC+CE=516+34=1568, so by the Pythagorean Theorem, AE=52013. You can now use similar triangles to find that x=5138 and continue on like in solution 2.
Solution 4
DE goes through A, the point of tangency of both circles. So DE intercepts equal arcs in circle P and Q: homothety. Hence, AE=4AD. We will use such similarity later.
The diagonal distance between the centers of the circles is 4+1=5. The difference in heights is 4−1=3. So BC=52−32=4.
The triangle connecting the centers with a side parallel to BC is a 3−4−5 right triangle. Since OPA=1, the height of A is 1+3/5=8/5. Drop an altitude from A to BC and call it I: IB=4/5 and IC=4−4/5=16/5. Since right △AIB∼△CIB, ABC is a right triangle also; IB:IA:IC form a geometric progression ×2.
Extend BA through A to a point G on the other side of ∘Q. By homothety, △DAB∼△EAG. By angle chasing △DAB through right triangle ABC, we deduce that ∠CEG is a right angle. Since ACEG is cyclic, ∠GAC is also right. So CG is a diameter of ∘G. Because of this, CG⊥BC, the tangent line. △BCG is right and △BCG∼△ABC∼△CAG.
AC=(8/5)2+(16/5)2=85/5 so AG=2AC=165/5 and [△CAG]=64/5.
Since [△DAB]=[△ACE], the common area is [ACEG]/17. 16[△DAB]=[△GAE] because the triangles are similar with a ratio of 1:4. So we only need to find [△CEG] now.
Extend DE through E to intersect the tangent at F. Because 4DA=AE, the altitude from B to AD is 4 times the height from C to EA. So BC=3/4BF and BF=16/3. We look at right triangle △AIF. IF=68/15 and AI=8/5. △AIF is a 17−6−513 right triangle. Hypotenuse AF intersects CG at a point, we call it H. CH=4/3÷68/15⋅8/5=8/17. So HG=8−8/17=128/17.
By Power of a Point, CH⋅HG=AH⋅HE. AH=16/5⋅513/17=1613/17. So HE=1024/289⋅17/(1613)=64/(1713). The height from E to CG is 17/(513)⋅64/(1713)=64/65.
Thus, [△CEG]=64/65⋅8÷2=256/65. The area of the whole cyclic quadrilateral is 64/5+256/65=(832+256)/65=1088/65. Lastly, the common area is 1/17 the area of the quadrilateral, or 64/65. So 64+65=129.
Solution 5 (HARD computation)
Consider the homothety that takes triangle BDA onto CXY on the big circle, as plotted. Some hidden congruence angles are revealed which help reduce computation complexity. Just some angle chasing and straight forward trigs. Because AE=XY and AE∥XY, XYE is right angle.
[AEC]=21AE∗CE∗sin∠ACE=21AE∗8sin∠CYE∗51[CXY]=21CX∗XY∗sin∠CXY=21∗8sin∠XYC∗XY∗sin∠CAY
Since ∠CAY=90−∠AYC, ∠XYC=90−∠CYE, XY=AE, we have
[CXY]=21∗8AEcos∠CYE∗cos∠AYC=21∗8AEcos∠CYE∗52
Since △CXY is four times in scale to △AEC, their area ratio is 16. Divide the two equations for the two areas, we have
tan∠CYE=81
With this angle found, everything else just follows.
sin∠CYE=1+tan2∠CYEtan∠CYE=651cos∠CYE=658sin∠AYE=sin(∠AYC+∠CYE)=51∗658+52∗651=132AE=8sin∠AYE=1316[AEC]=21∗8∗1316∗651∗51=6564
Thus, our answer is 64+65=129.
Solution 6 (Simple computation)
Let K be the intersection of BC and AE. Since the radii of the two circles are 1:4, so we have AD:AE=1:4, and the distance from B to line l and the distance from C to line l are in a ratio of 4:1, so BK:CK=4:1. We can easily calculate the length of BC to be 4, so CK=34. Let J be the foot of perpendicular line from A to BC, we can know that BJ:CJ=1:4, so BJ=0.8, CJ=3.2, AJ=1.6, and AK=1.62+(3.2+34)2=3413. Since CK2=EK⋅AK, so EK=39413, and AE=3413−39413=131613. sin∠AKB=AKAJ=34131.6=131.2, so the distance from C to line l is d=CK⋅sin∠AKB=34⋅131.2=131.6. so the area is
[ACE]=21⋅AE⋅d=21⋅131613131.6=6564
The final answer is 129.
--- by Dan Li
Solution 7
Consider the common tangent from A to both circles. Let this intersect BC at point K. From equal tangents, we have BK=AK=CK, which implies that ∠BAC=90∘.
Let the center of P be O1, and the center of Q be O2. Angle chasing, we find that △O1DA∼△O2EA with a ratio of 1:4. Hence 4AD=AE.
We can easily deduce that BC=4 by dropping an altitude from O1 to O2C. Let ∠ABC=θ. By some simple angle chasing, we obtain that ∠BO1A=2∠BDA=2∠ABC=2θ, and similarly ∠CO2A=180−2θ.
Using LoC, we get that AB=2−2cos2θ and AC=32+32cos2θ. From Pythagorean theorem, we have
AB2+AC2=BC2⟹cos2θ=−53⟹cosθ=51,sinθ=52
In other words, AB=54,AC=58.
Using the area condition, we have:
21AD∗ABsin∠DABAD∗54sin∠DABsin∠DAB⟹sin∠DAB=21AE∗ACsin(90−∠DAB)=4AD∗58cos∠DAB=8cos∠DAB=658
Now, for brevity, let ∠D=∠ADB and ∠A=∠DAB.
From Law of Sines on △ABD, we have
sin∠DAB52542AD=sin(180−∠A−∠D)AD=sin∠Acos∠D+sin∠Dcos∠AAD=132AD=134
It remains to find the area of △ABD. This is just
21AD∗AB∗sin∠A=21∗134∗54∗658=6564
for an answer of 129.
This solution was brought to you by Leonard_my_dude.
Solution 8 (Synthetic-Trigonometry)
Add in the line k as the internal tangent between the two circles. Let M be the midpoint of BC; It is well-known that M is on k and because k is the radical axis of the two circles, AM=BM=CM. Therefore because M is the circumcenter of △BAC, ∠BAC=90∘. Let OP be the center of circle P and likewise let OQ be the center of circle Q. It is well known that by homothety OP,A, and OQ are collinear. It is well-known that ∠ABC=∠ADB=b, and likewise ∠ACB=∠AEC=c. By homothety, AD=4AE, therefore since the two triangles mentioned in the problem, the length of the altitude from B to AD is four times the length of the altitude from C to AE. Using the Pythagorean Theorem, BC=4. By angle-chasing, OPAMB is cyclic, and likewise OQCMA is cyclic. Use the Pythagorean Theorem for △OPBM to get OPM=5. Then by Ptolemy's Theorem AB=545⟹AC=585. Now to compute the area, using what we know about the length of the altitude from B to AD is four times the length of the altitude from C to AE, letting x be the length of the altitude from C to AE, x=5138. From the Law of Sines, sinABD=2⟹sinA=AB4x⟹BD=AB8x=651665. Then use the Pythagorean Theorem twice and add up the lengths to get AD=134. Use the formula 2b×h to get 6564=129 as the answer.
~First
Solution 9 (Visual)
Let P and Q be the centers of circles P and Q , respectively.
Let M be midpoint BC,β=∠ACB.
Upper diagram shows that
sin2β=54 and AC=2AB. Therefore cos2β=53.
Let CH⊥l,BH′⊥l. Lower diagram shows that
∠CAE=∠ABH′=α (perpendicular sides)
and ∠CQE=2α (the same intersept CE⌢).
tanα=81,sin2α=1+tan2α2tanα=6516,cos2α=1+tan2α1−tan2α=6563.
The area
Solution 10 (Similar Triangles, Angle Chasing, and Ptolemy's)
We begin by extending AB upwards until it intersects Circle Q. We can call this point of intersection F. Connect F with E, C, and A for future use.
Create a trapezoid with points B, C, and the origins of Circles P and Q. After quick inspection, we can conclude that the distance between the origins is 5 and that BC is 4.
(Note: It is important to understand that we could simply use the formula for the distance between the tangent points on a line and two different circles, which is 2⋅a⋅b, where a and b are the two respective radii of the circles. In our case, we get 2⋅4=4.
Using similar triangles or homotheties, AE=4⋅AD and AF=4⋅BA. BC2=BA⋅BF.
16=BA⋅(5⋅BA)BA=54AF=516BF=4⋅5
Inspecting △BFC, we recognize that it is a right triangle (∠BCF=90) as the final length (FC) being 8 would allow for an x−2x−x5 triangle. Hence, the diameter of circle Q = CF. This also means that ∠CAF=∠CEF=90.
From the fact that △ABC is a right triangle:
AB2+AC2=BC2AC=58
(Note: We could have also used △FAC.)
Our next step is to start angle chasing to find any other similar triangles or shared angles. Label the intersection between FC and DE as M. Label ∠CAE=∠CFE=θ. Since ∠BAC=90, ∠EAF=∠DAB=90−θ. Now, use the sine formula and the fact that the areas of △DBA and △ACE are equal to get:
21⋅AC⋅AE⋅sinθ=21⋅AD⋅AB⋅sin(90−θ)
Since sin(90−θ)=cosθ:
tanθ=2⋅AEAD
Using right △FCE, since ∠ACM=∠CFE, tanθ=FECE. Hence, plugging into the previous equation:
FECE=2⋅AEAD
Using the Pythagorean theorem on △FCE, FE=(64−CE2). We also know that AE=4⋅AD Plugging back in:
(64−CE2)CE=2⋅(4⋅AD)AD(64−CE2)CE=81
. From here, we can square both sides and bring everything to one side to get:
EF2+64EF−64=0
.
EF=6564CE=658
We should also return to the fact that sinθ=CFCE from △FCE, so
sinθ=651
From the fact that ∠CAF=∠CEF=90, we can use Ptolemy's Theorem on quadrilateral ACEF. AC⋅EF+CE⋅FA=CF⋅AE. Plugging in and solving, we get that AE=1316.
We now have all of our pieces to use the Sine Formula on △ACE.
Let the center of the larger circle be O, and the center of the smaller circle be P. It is not hard to find the areas of ACO and ABP using pythagorean theorem, which are 532 and 52 respectively. Assign ∠AOC=a,∠COE=c,∠DPB=d,∠BPA=b. We can figure out that ∠AOE=∠DOA=θ using vertical angles and isosceles triangles. Now, using [ABC]=21absinC
[ACE]=[AOC]+[COE]−[AOC]=532−8sinc−8sinθ,[DAB]=[APD]+[APB]+[BPD]=52+21sinθ+21sind.
We can also figure out that sina=54,cosa=53,sinb=54,cosb=−53. Also, c=θ−a and d=360−θ−b. Using sum and difference identities:
sinc=53sinθ−54cosθ,sind=53sinθ−54cosθ.
(We can also notice that c+d=360−θ−b+θ−a=360−(a+b)=180 which means that sinc=sind.) Substituting in the equations for sinc and sind into the equations for [ACE] and [DAB], setting them equal, and simplifying:
3=2sinθ+3cosθ.
Solving this equation we get that sinθ=1312 and cosθ=135. Doing a lot of substitution gives us
[ACE]=[DAB]=6564,
which means the answer is 64+65=129.
~BS2012
Solution 12 (Coordinates and Shoelace)
Let the centers of circles P and Q be P and Q, respectively. Let F be the point on QC such that PF is parallel to BC. We find that BC=PF=(4+1)2−(4−1)2=4.
Now, we define A to be (0,0). It follows that:
\begin{align} P &= \left(-\frac{4}{5},-\frac{3}{5}\right) \\ Q &= \left(\frac{16}{5},\frac{12}{5}\right) \\ B &= \left(-\frac{4}{5},-\frac{8}{5}\right) \\ C &= \left(\frac{16}{5},-\frac{8}{5}\right) \\ \end{align}
The equation of circle P is (x+54)2+(y+53)2=12, which simplifies to x2+58x+y2+56y=0.
The equation of circle Q is (x−516)2+(y−512)2=42, which simplifies to x2−532x+y2−524y=0.
Suppose points D and E lie on the line y=mx for some slope m. We can now plug in y=mx into the equations for the circles to find the coordinates of D and E in terms of m.
For point D:
x2+58x+m2x2+56mx=0(1+m2)x2+(58+56m)=0
Since D=A, we have x=0, thus x=1+m2−(58+56m).
For point E:
x2−532x+m2x2−524mx=0(1+m2)x2−(532+524m)=0
Since E=A, we have x=0, thus x=1+m2(532+524m).
We let a=1+m2(58+56m) to write things quicker, and so the coordinates of D are (−a,−am) and the coordinates of E are (4a,4am).
Now, we can apply shoelace on △DBA and △ACE: [DBA]=21(0⋅−58+−54⋅−am+−a⋅0)−(0⋅−54+−58⋅−a+−am⋅0)=2−54am+58a=258a−54am.
Note on determining the absolute value: We can assume −21because\overline{CA}hasaslopeof-\frac{1}{2}andtheareaof\triangle ACEgetstoobigifm>0.So,wecanalsoassumea$ is positive.
Equating the two areas yields 258a−54am=2532a+564am⟹−524a=568am⟹m=−176.
We also know that a=1+m2(58+56m)=1+2893658−8536=28932585100=6568.
Now, we can compute the area of △DBA: [DBA]=258⋅6568−54⋅6568⋅(−176)=25⋅658⋅68+4⋅4⋅6=6564⟹m+m=129.